When we discuss ethics and compliance in the boardroom we need data. In some areas this need is clear - nowhere is it more true than as the murky facts emerge in investigations. But I would argue that Chief Compliance Officers (CCOs) should capture and use data when discussing regulation and even culture with the board. In this blog we’ve set out how to use data in these two ‘data light’ areas.
Creating Useful Data on Ethical Culture
Too often board discussions about culture are led by ‘gut feeling’ or misleading anecdotes, which are faulty premises for formal decisions. So how do we as CCOs lead a more data-driven discussion about culture with boards?
Surveys, for all their drawbacks, are a good way to give structured insights on culture. Human Resources (HR) teams have become adept at broader workplace surveys, complemented by shorter ‘pulse surveys’ and the like. If we’re lucky, compliance teams will get a few questions included in these surveys and maybe even invited to discuss the results in the management team. But this discussion often doesn’t involve the CCO, is very high level and covers questions that aren’t overly useful for our purposes.
I have spent significant efforts convincing HR to include more targeted, useful questions on observations of non-compliance or why people didn’t report issues they observed. In the end I have developed a different approach, as described below.
My team and I select a group of 50 to 100 leaders who make a significant impact on our risk management efforts and the CEO launches the project with a letter underlining why compliance is so important to the organisation. The 50-100 ‘risk leaders’ complete a short survey on items that are truly actionable for compliance teams (maximum 10 questions). I also ask the leaders to fill out a proactive conflict of interest declaration. The results are analysed and used in one-on-one discussions between the CCO and each individual risk leader that last between 45 and 60 minutes.
This project produces tangible data for the board on culture and is virtually cost-free. It’s a great way to meet senior people and initiate difficult conversations on compliance. I’ve now used the project four times in different organisations and have always seen positive developments both in the wider organisation and for individual leaders. The one-on-one discussions are a powerful aspect of the project, allowing learnings to be taken in judgment-free environment. You can quickly align an outlying leader with their peers by pointing to the survey responses and sharing their colleagues’ best practices for leadership on ethics and compliance.
Simple Visualisation Technique for Providing Regulatory Updates
Data doesn’t always have to be graphs and numbers – there is a happy medium to be found on topics like regulatory updates (which can too often be presented as dry memos in prose).
When it comes to regulation, there is always a risk of an imbalanced conversation between the CCO and the Board. The CCO is the expert, yet board members are the decision-makers, so communicating with clarity is essential. What board members need to know is – Have we captured all the regulations that impact us at present and in future? What are the impacts? And how well prepared are we?
Data visualisation can help to give clarity and to address the risk of imbalance, at the same time as making decisions and board scrutiny easier. Here is an example:
Across the x-axis is the potential impact on the organisation, with preparedness across the y-axis. The colour coding gives a rough indication of where the board should focus its attention – red for high alertness and green for topics that have lower impact or where the company looks to be fully prepared. Each regulation has some simple labelling to ease discussion, including the year when the regulation came / will come into force.
There are lots of potential improvements and tailoring to this visualisation, but you can see how instinctive and useful it is to a board compared to a long memorandum. One could imagine colour-coding for the labels that indicate which division(s) might be impacted. Or different-sized bubbles for financial investments required for preparation.
Discuss Data Openly with Your Board
If I could give one piece of advice for using data in the boardroom, it would be to create the right environment for the discussions ahead.
Open a direct conversation as early as possible in your relationship with the board. Don’t assume that they want a lot of data; instead, listen to their views on the current set of materials, what works and what doesn’t.
There will be limitations on what you can deliver, so make sure that these are clear up-front. You will need to time to create the systems and governance to capture certain data sets, so don’t leave the board with any doubt that delivering on some metrics is a work in progress.
Overall data is a great way to step away from gut feelings or anecdotes when making board decisions. You can tell stories from your compliance programme using the hard facts that you and your teams have patiently gathered. These stories will be more impactful if you’ve prepared the board for the discussions ahead.